Press ESC or click the X to close this window

Maidstone Symphony Orchestra 14 October 2023 (Susan Elkin reviews)


The opening item in the first concert of Maidstone Symphony Orchestra’s 113th season was Smetana’s overture to The Bartered Bride. It’s one of those “lot of notes” pieces with an terrifyingly exposed second violin passage  but in Brian Wright’s warmly safe hands, MSO delivered it at a nippy tempo and with appropriate exuberance. The orchestral sound was, as ever, beautifully balanced. This is Wright’s 33rd season with the orchestra and that total, long established trust between him and the players shines through.

Brian Wright


Then came British cellist Maxim Calver to play Shostokovitch’s first cello concerto (1959) – his third concert with the orchestra. This bleak, anguished but beautiful concerto has become quite well known since at least two people (Guy Johnston and Sheku Kanneh-Mason) have won BBC Young Musician of the year with it. Calver’s playing was both intense and insouciant as he hammered out those relentless, menacing rhythms in the first movement. I loved the brooding, legato lament he dug out of the slow movement and his mellow mournfulness of tone in the cadenza – carefully applying vibrato to some notes and not others as much Shostokovitch string writing seems to demand. He followed the concerto with Pablo Casals’s  sorrowful Song of the Birds as his encore, and hinted it was a way of marking these “sad times”.



And so to Brahms’s first symphony, often regarded as a homage to Beethoven, although it’s a lot more than that. Wright set it going with all the grandiloquent panache it needs and brought out plenty of nicely balanced lyrical wind detail in the first movement. The andante gives us one of Brahms’s many lovely oboe melodies played here with gentle passion and the violin solo (leader Andrew Laing) with the horn at the end of the movement was arrestingly moving. After a lilting allegretto – a sort of descendant of the classical minuet and trio – Wright delivered the big Beethovenian melody in the final movement with all the right Brahmsian spin and some attractive flute work. And all this was achieved with commensurate professionalism despite a distracting problem with Mote Hall’s lighting rig in the second half.

It was a fine and enjoyable concert overall and if one or two players were, unusually for MSO, not having the best of nights the hiccoughs were pretty brief and would have passed almost unnoticed by most of the audience.



Author information
Susan Elkin Susan Elkin is an education journalist, author and former secondary teacher of English. She was Education and Training Editor at The Stage from 2005 - 2016
More posts by Susan Elkin