Shakespeare’s Cousin
Jonathan Moore, who also directs
AMDG Productions
White Bear Theatre, Kennington
Star rating: 2
Photo credit: Kai Dorovk
Robert Southwell (Danny Solomon) was an Elizabethan poet, highly acclaimed at the time. He was also a Jesuit priest in an age when re-established Protestantism was ruthlessly persecuting such men. In order to make much sense of all this you need to know that Henry VIII destroyed the monasteries in the 1530s, that his daughter Mary Tudor tried with many executions to return the country to Catholicism in the 1550s and then Elizabeth enforced Protestantism for the rest of the century – and permanently as it turned out. If you don’t know your history you’ll flounder with this play although you might ponder the parallels between the Reformation and Brexit.
It starts in the country home of Sir Richard Topcliffe (Robin Kingsland) genially entertaining (to start with) Southwell who has just been captured after six years in hiding, Topcliffe is one of Elizabeth’s leading interrogators and has a torture chamber in his cellar. Later the scene shifts to the Tower. His brief is to force out of Southwell the whereabouts of his fellow Jesuits and the identity of their leader. He doesn’t succeed.
In the second act, Southwell, now very battered, is visited in the Tower by a chirpy relation in disguise – William Shakespeare (Alex Townson). And the ending at Tyburn is inevitable, complete with a hideously graphic account of hanging, drawing and quartering.
All three actors deliver strong performances and Kingsland is outstanding. His Topcliffe is slimy but vulnerable, despite his power. He enjoys the cruelty he inflicts and talks with chilling casualness about the women he has raped and tortured. On the other hand we really do believe that he loves his wife and children and that he has persuaded himself that his cold, logical, hatred of Catholicism justifies his actions. It’s nicely nuanced.
Solomon provides a clear contrast – he makes Southwell nervous and frightened but resolutely sustained by his belief. He argues, when he gets the chance, in favour of mutual tolerance and most of us empathise with that. He does the suffering very convincingly.
In some ways Townson has the most difficult role. He has to find a plausible way of presenting the best known man of the era and it doesn’t always sit quite right as he grins his way round the dingy cell before getting more serious.
This is a very wordy play and it’s too long. It’s billed at two hours with interval but actually runs for two and a quarter. It could easily lose twenty minutes especially from the protracted end. The dialogue is awkward too. Of course playwright/director, Jonathan Moore is looking for ways of reminding us that we’re in late 16th century but to use modern language punctuated with “Coz” and “Sirrah’ and obsolete possessive pronouns such as “mine own” is not a satisfactory way of doing it. I enjoyed the hidden Shakespeare quotes though – they come thick and fast and that’s fun but I don’t think this play is meant to be a treasure hunt for literary buffs.
Incidentally and on a very personal note, I had failed to notice the trigger warning about torture probably because I am usually gung-ho about trigger warnings. There were, though, several points in Act One – strappado and thumb screws, vividly described and then enacted – when, had this been TV I would have switched off immediately. As it was, I got through by closing my eyes tightly as I do for the blinding of Gloucester in King Lear and the murder of the Macduff children in Macbeth. Ironically, it is testament to the quality of the acting in this play that it got to me so distressingly.